Despite this moment of uncertainty and volatility, leaders can still create workplace conditions where people feel seen, trusted, and part of something meaningful.
In recent months, uncertainty has become the norm across the nonprofit world. Organizations are experiencing funding shifts, leadership transitions, operational pivots, and even challenges to their core missions.
These changes demand more of you and your teams while offering fewer guarantees. In these moments, just steering your organization can take enormous skill; but even skilled organizational management may not be enough. As a leader, you are also facing the additional challenge of keeping people connected, motivated, and hopeful in these moments of uncertainty.
The good news is that you have the power to create workplace conditions where people still feel seen, trusted, and part of something meaningful when the path ahead is unclear. With the right approaches, leaders can keep teams inspired and engaged, despite the chaos.
Here are eight strategies to keep your team invested when it feels like the ground is shifting beneath them.
1. Communicate Early, Often, and Transparently
You need to control the narrative. In an information vacuum, people fill in the blanks on their own. And more often than not, they fill it with fear. That’s why regular, clear, and honest communication is essential, even more so when the news isn’t all good.
Transparent communication builds trust. Even when leaders don’t have all the answers, sharing what is known (and acknowledging what isn’t) shows respect. It also reinforces a sense of shared reality and purpose. The more informed people are, the more equipped they are to navigate uncertainty with clarity and focus.
What to do:
- Hold regular town halls or all-staff updates.
- Share the why behind difficult decisions.
- Make communication two-way—encourage questions, concerns, and dialogue.
2. Build and Demonstrate Mutual Trust
Trust isn’t just something employees owe leadership. It must flow both ways. And it’s not just about saying the right things, it’s about demonstrating trust through action.
Leaders build trust by honoring commitments, listening actively, and being consistent. But they also show trust by empowering others: delegating authority, encouraging initiative, and giving people room to lead.
What to do:
- Delegate decisions, not just tasks.
- Avoid micromanagement and trust people to do their jobs.
- Hold yourself accountable to the same standards you expect of others.
3. Assign Work That Is Challenging and Mission Aligned
People stay engaged when their work feels meaningful and matches their capabilities. They check out when it doesn’t. The best leaders help team members find relevance in their roles and ensure they’re working in ways that stretch and fulfill them.
Passion isn’t always enough to keep your teams focused and productive. People need work that stimulates, challenges, and uses their unique skills. People want to grow. They want to contribute. And they want their effort to matter.
What to do:
- Connect everyday tasks to the bigger mission.
- Set roles and responsibilities that align with individuals’ strengths.
- Ensure people are both challenged and supported in their work.
4. Create Opportunities for Input
Engagement rises when people feel they have a voice. That doesn’t mean decisions need to be democratic, but it does mean that employees should be invited into planning, strategy, and evaluation whenever possible. Direct people where they can be involved.
Participation fosters ownership. When people have a hand in shaping a plan, they’re more likely to commit to its success. Even contributing within defined parameters can be deeply empowering. Budgeting, goal setting, or process improvement are concrete, meaningful tasks that activate team members.
What to do:
- Build cross-functional teams to tackle organizational challenges.
- Use surveys and facilitated sessions to gather input.
- Design annual or quarterly planning processes that include broad staff participation.
5. Focus on Fewer, More Meaningful Initiatives
Uncertainty often tempts leaders to launch new initiatives in hopes of signaling momentum. But too many initiatives can create confusion, mission creep, and fatigue.
Prioritize the few essential efforts that advance your mission and double down on seeing them through. It’s better to move a few solid pillars than to scatter your team’s energy across dozens of unfinished plans.
What to do:
- Avoid wasting work.
- Set clear goals and stick with them.
- Celebrate milestones and progress along the way.
6. Make Space to Learn from Mistakes
When stress is high, it’s easy to move quickly from one problem to the next. But nothing kills motivation like witnessing your organization make the same mistake time and again. Sustainable organizations learn from what went wrong so they don’t keep repeating the same mistakes.
Teams that are encouraged to reflect, evaluate, and adapt are more resilient in the long run. When leadership creates the space for reflection, mistakes become growth opportunities instead of morale killers.
What to do:
- Hold regular retrospectives or debriefs after major initiatives.
- Normalize failure as part of experimentation.
- Document and apply lessons to future work.
7. Model and Support Work-Life Flexibility
In high-stress environments, employees often feel pressure to overperform or overextend. This problem is especially common in mission-driven sectors.
Creating an environment where structure is clear, yet flexibility is encouraged and demonstrated within that structure, can help keep employees invested—especially during particularly tough moments.
Leaders must model the boundaries they want their teams to maintain. That means honoring time off, discouraging after-hours communication, and showing that rest and recovery are not signs of weakness but of responsibility. This can feel counterproductive when you already feel there is not enough time, but preventing burnout leads to higher productivity and longer tenures over time.
What to do:
- Set and respect boundaries around structure.
- Normalize a flexible approach to work-life integration.
- Talk openly about wellness and burnout prevention.
8. Be Aware of the System You’re Operating In
In sectors like nonprofits, schools, and human services, people often stay because they believe in the mission. While this alignment with mission is a deeply important part of the job, there can also be a perception that it is used to justify overwork, underpay, or systemic inefficiencies.
Understanding and navigating structural realities, like funding limitations or burdensome reporting requirements, are part of leading a nonprofit organization. But it is also important to understand how these realities can breed burnout and disengagement, no matter how strong the internal culture is.
When possible, leaders may look outside their organizations to advocate for broader sector-level changes that allow people to do their best work without feeling exploited by the system. This in turn will help managers recruit and retain strong talent in the sector.
What to do:
- Acknowledge the constraints your team operates under.
- Invest in the long-term work needed to set new standards and build better systems.
- Engage with external partners to build trust-based practices.
Conclusion
Uncertainty isn’t going away. But disengagement doesn’t have to be the default. The best leaders balance structure and flexibility in their cultures and avoid trying to control every outcome. This enables employees to thrive in ambiguity and empowers them to show up with clarity, purpose, and trust.
By focusing on communication, shared decision-making, meaningful work, and systemic awareness, leaders can build teams that stay resilient and motivated no matter what comes next.
Your Nonprofit Executive Search Partner
At Lindauer, we partner with mission-driven organizations to find the leaders who will propel their causes forward.